appwindiscover
Back to the radar

Engineering. Why RevenueCat ditched custom AI for paywall design

RevenueCat

Original title: Don’t build your own harness: lessons from building Paywalls AI Editor

RevenueCat launched an AI editor for their remotely configurable paywalls product earlier this year, enabling users to collaborate with an agent to create or modify paywalls. While adoption metrics showed promising growth and the agent technically completed assigned tasks, user feedback and internal testing revealed a critical gap: quantitative metrics failed to capture qualitative friction in the user experience. The team encountered a turning point when users began reporting that the AI-generated solutions felt unfair or suboptimal, suggesting the underlying model wasn't truly understanding paywall design principles or user intent.

This experience taught RevenueCat a valuable lesson about the limits of building custom AI harnesses for specialized domain problems. Rather than continuing to refine their proprietary agent, the team recognized that leveraging existing, battle-tested AI platforms might better serve their users' needs while reducing maintenance burden. For mobile app studios, this underscores a broader principle: not every workflow deserves a custom AI solution. Sometimes adopting proven third-party tools, even if they require workflow adaptation, delivers better user outcomes than investing heavily in bespoke AI development. The key is measuring beyond vanity metrics like adoption rate and listening closely to qualitative user sentiment to catch misalignment early.

Read next